Is Vladimir Guerrero Jr. No Longer A Generational Talent? With Mike Wilner - The Homestand Show

June 13, 2023

The Toronto Blue Jays embarked on a crucial nine-game road trip, facing tough opponents in the highly competitive AL East. Coming off a loss to the division rivals, the Blue Jays aimed to turn their fortunes around as they kicked off the series against the Baltimore Orioles in Baltimore.

To provide insights and preview the upcoming games, Mike Wilner from the Toronto Star joined the discussion. Wilner, known for his comprehensive analysis, had not been on air since the demotion of promising pitcher Alek Manoah to the Florida Complex League. The hosts were eager to hear Wilner's initial reaction and his opinion on the timing of Manoah's demotion.

"I don't believe they waited too long," Wilner stated. He expressed his belief that after Manoah's disastrous last start, it was evident he needed a break. Giving up six runs and facing only nine hitters in one out, Manoah's performance was abysmal. Wilner mentioned a column he wrote for the Toronto Star, where he discussed Ricky Romero's perspective on the matter. Sending Manoah down to Buffalo allowed him to take a step back, rejuvenate, and address the issues he was facing.

Chris Bassett, a prominent pitcher, voiced support for Manoah and highlighted that setbacks like these were a common part of the game. However, Wilner disagreed with the notion that it was a commonplace occurrence. He emphasized the unusual circumstances surrounding Manoah's demotion, considering his exceptional rookie year and Cy Young candidacy in his second year. While acknowledging that fans and the media tend to overreact, Wilner underscored the significance of the situation. Sending a player of Manoah's caliber all the way down to a lower league was a rarity for the franchise.

The conversation shifted to potential replacements for Manoah in the rotation. Wilner discussed the possibility of Trevor Richards being stretched out to start games. However, he also acknowledged Richards' valuable contributions out of the bullpen. While few options were readily available, Wilner believed that any replacement would provide more consistent performances than Manoah had during the first two months of the season.

As the focus turned to the upcoming road trip, the hosts and Wilner acknowledged the challenges ahead. The Blue Jays were set to face the Baltimore Orioles, the Texas Rangers, and the surprising Miami Marlins—a formidable test for the team. Despite the difficulty, Wilner stressed the importance of winning series, especially against teams ahead of the Blue Jays in the standings.

Wilner also addressed concerns about Vladimir Guerrero Jr.'s recent performance. Recognizing Guerrero Jr.'s young age and immense potential, Wilner emphasized that he was a generational talent who had already achieved remarkable feats in the game. While Guerrero Jr. may experience slumps, Wilner expressed confidence in his ability to bounce back and contribute significantly to the team's success.

In conclusion, the Blue Jays faced an arduous road trip against tough opponents within their division. The challenges ahead required a strong performance from the team, while the demotion of Alec Manoa created opportunities for other pitchers to step up. With the support of players like Vladimir Guerrero Jr., the Blue Jays aimed to navigate this demanding stretch of games and solidify their position in the playoff race.