Is it time to give up on Alek Manoah's Season? - The Homestand Show

It seems like you're discussing Alek Manoah and his role as a starting pitcher for the Toronto Blue Jays. There are different perspectives on what level of performance is expected from him. Some believe that he doesn't necessarily have to be at his peak form and can be effective as a fourth or fifth starter, as long as he can eat innings and provide serviceable performances. This would be seen as a positive contribution to the team's rotation.

You mention that his recent outings in Double-A and against Detroit have shown promise, but you're not sure if he's ready to perform at that same level against stronger offenses. There may be doubts about his ability to consistently locate his pitches and handle potent lineups. You express a desire for him to succeed and reach his potential, but you personally have reservations about whether he can perform at an elite level this season.

It's worth noting that athletes go through ups and downs, and it can take time for them to develop and reach their full potential. While Manoah has faced challenges, he is still a young pitcher with room to grow. As a fan, you want to see him perform well and contribute to the team's success, but you may have concerns about his readiness to do so against stronger opponents.

Overall, it's important to remember that player development is a process, and it's not uncommon for young pitchers to experience ups and downs. The hope is that Manoah will continue to progress and become a reliable contributor for the team in the future.