Do the Blue Jays sacrifice Alek Manaoh?

When it comes to the Toronto Blue Jays' pursuit of an elite starting pitcher, the question arises: Should they include Alek Manoah in a trade package? In this blog post, we will analyze the possibility of such a trade and discuss the value Manoah brings to the table. While the decision ultimately depends on the circumstances and the team's acceptance of acquiring Manoah, it's important to consider the potential impact of adding an experienced pitcher to the Blue Jays' roster.

Including Manoah in a trade for an elite starting pitcher is a viable option, provided the acquiring team acknowledges that they are receiving the player from the previous season, not the current one. The Blue Jays need to ensure that the potential trade partner recognizes Manoah's capabilities and talent. Although there may be concerns about obtaining fair value in return for him, it remains a possibility if the conditions are favourable.

While Manoah would not necessarily be the centrepiece of the trade, he would certainly play a crucial role. As a promising young pitcher, he possesses immense potential. However, it is essential to understand that a trade involving Manoah would likely require additional assets from the Blue Jays to sweeten the deal. The team would need to balance the value they receive in return while considering Manoah's significance to their future success.

Trading Manoah becomes a more challenging decision when considering his potential for improvement and long-term contributions. With another year of arbitration control, the Blue Jays' management, following the approach of Atkins and Shapiro, tends to prioritize long-term assets rather than short-term rentals. Manoah's potential for growth and the control the team maintains over him until 2028 make him a valuable asset to retain.

While the idea of trading Manoah is intriguing, it is crucial to consider alternative options. The Blue Jays' current roster is already strong enough to compete, but acquiring a couple of impactful players could further bolster their chances of success in the playoffs. However, it is important to approach potential trades with a focus on long-term team building rather than temporary solutions.

When contemplating trades for big-name pitchers like Musgrove, Snell, Darvish, Scherzer, or Verlander, the financial aspect plays a significant role. Acquiring players with substantial contracts may prove challenging for the Blue Jays. Despite the allure of such acquisitions, it is essential to remain pragmatic and consider the team's financial limitations.

As the Toronto Blue Jays continue to seek an elite starting pitcher, the possibility of including Alek Manoah in a trade arises. The decision hinges on various factors, including the acquiring team's acceptance of Manoah's previous performance and the potential value the Blue Jays could receive in return. Ultimately, the team's long-term strategy and financial considerations should guide their decision-making process. While trading Manoah remains an option, the Blue Jays must carefully weigh the benefits and drawbacks to ensure a favourable outcome for their future success.

Full video: